On the spring from 2023, Maddi realized their experience of Fravel are falling apart, and she is actually savagely sincere with her father.

David Kingsbury: She states, you realize, dad … I know my family understands they. … I’m sure my pals understand it. And you may I am ashamed about any of it, but I’m not sure what to do about it. But Maddi had entered Tinder, which is where she reconnected with Sullivan, just who she know away sexiest german girls from school. Spencer Sullivan: We were family unit members towards the Facebook, thus i know you to she got students … As it looks like, Sullivan including knew Fravel away from Winona Condition. Spencer Sullivan: He had been in the same fraternity once i are. Peter Van Sant: Let me know concerning Adam you knew back then. Spencer Sullivan: The guy and i also don’t most chat all that much.

Maddi told Sullivan one to she and you will Fravel got reached the purpose of zero return. Spencer Sullivan: The two of us type of offered to keep it miracle anywhere between us until she is actually on her very own. Mostly, the relationship try a key out of Fravel. Maddi’s relatives and you may girlfriends realized about it, in addition they told police on Sullivan when Maddi went forgotten. Which is whenever investigators titled Sullivan in for an interview. Spencer Sullivan: These people were … just types of asking me standard questions relating to once we had started matchmaking. … in which was indeed your at this point, what have been your doing so far? Peter Van Sant: Exactly what was your undertaking into the ? Spencer Sullivan: Uh, one to early morning I happened to be at the office. Sullivan surrendered their phone if you are investigators examined their alibi. Because they investigated their facts, they also discovered of Maddi’s friends you to definitely simply half a dozen months in advance of she vanished, she in the end had advised Fravel in the Sullivan.

Megan Kingsbury: She don’t want to lie and you will she just – they bubbled upwards inside of her the fresh new – that it shame. Peter Van Sant: Will it be true that Maddi informed Adam in the Spencer? David Kingsbury: Yeah. Peter Van Sant: That’s a fairly gutsy action to take. Cathy Kingsbury: Uh, we want she hadn’t. All of it arrived raining away and Megan Kingsbury says Maddi told Fravel she are leaving him and seeking getting a condo where she’d accept its pupils. Peter Van Sant: And performed she inform you exactly how Adam responded into information?

Maddi and Sullivan began dating, but on the side

Megan Kingsbury: In my opinion she said the guy cried, in which he really was damage during the time. Theresa Sis Mejia: I know he had been really damage and you will heartbroken – unexpectedly, you can see away … she’s got feelings for an individual more and it’s more than. Ryan Fravel and Theresa Sibling Mejia CBS Development Fravel’s cousin Theresa, as well as their brother Ryan, state information of crack-upwards hurt them too, as the Maddi is a cherished member of the stretched loved ones. Ryan Fravel: Maddi is actually a sis to all people, and you can our hearts is actually … damaged. … I lost a virtually cherished one. They declare that, even when Adam Fravel and Maddi usually got an on-again, off-again relationships, it stayed to each other to possess seven decades. Theresa Sis Mejia: I was completely amazed when i learned that she is matchmaking Spencer behind my brother’s back. Maddi’s closest friend Katie Kolka states stress between Maddi and you can Fravel have been sky high immediately after her revelation in the Spencer. It was a single day before she disappeared.

I was not sure just what standing of your own dating was precisely that have, uh, Adam Fravel

Katie Kolka: She titled me personally crying and you will she questioned in the event the she you certainly will already been work at the house … She asserted that Adam try hovering more than their particular when you are she is operating and you will and make statements about additional people increasing his high school students and you will, you realize, could you be really planning exit me for the next man? … She felt very threatened. Maddi remaining their particular house and you may visited Kolka’s ahead of winding up during the Sullivan’s family, in addition to into the Winona. Spencer Sullivan: She came out over enjoy my birthday with me … she introduced two donuts we you will definitely broke up with each most other. She had something special in my situation. … It was a small LEGO place, a tiny Celebrity Wars LEGO lay. I experienced a credit of their therefore is actually a celebrity Battles credit. Peter Van Sant: That last go out your saw their unique person to person. Spencer Sullivan: I recall the woman is standing at my side tips. She turned into to and you may beamed at the me personally and you may waved and you may (sighs) that was the very last go out We spotted her. Within days of his interviews, cops affirmed Sullivan’s alibi and you can came back his phone. Eventually, cops say, he had been cleared. Maddi’s friend Hailey Scott says Spencer was the great thing so you can affect her in very long. Hailey Scott: Spencer shown their particular you to definitely she deserved way more than Adam. Spencer Sullivan CBS Development Sullivan says he was devastated in the wake away from Maddi’s disappearance.